Six Common Questions You Don’t Want to Answer—Until You Talk to a Car Accident Lawyer
When you’ve just been in an accident, you’re shaken up. Maybe hurt. Definitely overwhelmed. And yet—everyone seems to want answers right now. The problem? One wrong answer could hurt your claim. Here are 6 common questions you’ll likely be asked—and why you should hit pause before you answer.
1. “Were you injured?”
Why this question is risky:
You might not feel pain right away. Adrenaline, shock, and trauma can delay symptoms. If you say you’re fine, that statement can be used later to downplay or deny your injuries—especially if new symptoms develop days later.
What to say instead (if you’re put on the spot):
“I’m still shaken up and plan to get checked out—I’d prefer not to say anything more right now.”
2. “Whose fault was it?”
Why this question is risky:
Even if you think you were partially at fault, don’t admit it. You likely don’t know everything yet—there could be road hazards, mechanical issues, or negligent actions by other drivers that played a role.
What to say instead:
“I’m not sure yet—I think it’s best to wait until everything is reviewed.”
3. “Can you give a recorded statement?”
Why this question is risky:
This is usually asked by the other party’s insurance company—not yours. They’re trained to ask questions that get you to say something that weakens your case. Even small misstatements can be used against you.
What to say instead:
“I’ve been advised not to give any recorded statements until I speak with my attorney.”
4. “Did you see the other driver?”
Why this question is risky:
If you guess and you’re wrong, your credibility can be questioned. It’s okay not to have seen everything. Don’t let pressure make you speculate.
What to say instead:
“Things happened so fast—I’m not sure of the details yet.”
5. “Do you have any pre-existing injuries?”
Why this question is risky:
They’ll try to use this to argue that your pain wasn’t caused by the crash. But aggravation of a pre-existing condition is a valid legal claim—and your lawyer will need to frame that properly.
What to say instead:
“That’s something I’d rather go over with my attorney first.”
6. “Do you want to settle now?”
Why this question is risky:
Early settlement offers often come before you know the full extent of your injuries, long-term treatment needs, or missed work. Once you accept, you waive your right to ask for more.
What to say instead:
“I want to make sure I understand the full picture—I’ll need time to speak with a lawyer.”
One Answer Can Cost You Everything
Insurance adjusters and investigators are trained to move fast. They know the window before you get legal advice is their best chance to pay you less.
Don’t give them that chance. Call a trusted personal injury attorney before you answer anything. An experienced personal injury lawyer will protect your rights, handle the questions, and help you make the right moves from the start.
Need help now?
If you’re dealing with a situation like this, it’s smart to talk to someone who handles these issues every day. Our team at El Dabe Ritter Trial Lawyers is here to help. Call us anytime or submit the form below for a free consultation.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog post is not intended as legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. You should consult with an experienced attorney for advice on your specific situation.
